Texas 'wrongful birth' bill would allow doctors to lie, critics say
http://www.cnn.com/2017/03/06/health/wrongful-births-bill-texas-senate/index.html
A new bill being decided on in the Texas Senate called the Senate Bill 25 is currently causing a lot of uproar (for fair reason), according to Wayne Drash from CNN. The Senate Bill 25 is a bill that will prevent parents from suing their doctors if their children are born with disabilities. Essentially, this creates a loophole in that this bill might result in doctors lying to their patients about the condition of their baby in order to prevent them from aborting. However, supporters of this bill claim it is simply to protect both the rights of doctors from "wrongful birth" lawsuits and the rights of the disabled, and is overall founded on the idea that a life is not an "injury" in which parents would need damage payment for. Its flaws are pretty translucent as it seems, as Margret Johnson said this bill will allow doctors to withhold vital information on the babies health in order to prevent parents to make a formal decision on whether or not to continue with the birth. It is clear to see the anti-abortion aspect of this bill without explicitly saying it. The several issues are clear to see, this bill rights a wrong and will protect doctors, and will also allow doctors to impose their own moralities within these cases. Though the author includes lots of rhetoric against this bill, he also includes several positions of the Republican supporters, some of whom believe that current laws promote abortions which is why this bill is a necessary one. Despite this, it is clear throughout the article that this bill will allow for doctors to commit malpractice without getting the proper (or any) punishments for the damages they cause. In defiance of all the oppositions, the committee voted unanimously to send the bill to the full Senate.
As stated by several other very woke men and women throughout this article, the Senate Bill 25 is one that erects several questions and concerns. My ultimate reaction is that it is simply a bill to strip women of their reproductive rights without straight straightforwardly banning abortion. Instead, this bill creates a loophole that will allow for doctors to lie to patients about the health of their babies for extremely minimal punishment in return (if any). This bill is also an extreme threat to babies with potential disabilities, especially if action during pregnancy can be taken but the doctor fails to tell them due to the ideas that 1.) if they do tell the parents they might consider aborting the child (which the majority of Texans are against) and 2.) that they won't even be sued for lying so why not?!. I think it is ironic that this bill is be founded on the protection of the rights of the disabled when this bill in fact could put their lives at risk, especially if a doctor fails to tell the parents of a disability and the parents are then highly unprepared to take care of this child, and won't receive the funds normally provided from the lawsuit, therefore it does not protect the disabled in any way shape or form, other than preventing the termination of life that should not even be up to anyone other than the woman herself, let alone the government. In conclusion, I firmly believe this bill is horrendous and I hope for the sake of everyone in Texas that it dies in committee.